|
Location |
Names of Officers/
Individuals
Alleged by
Claimant
M Kirk BVSc |
Names of Officers/
Individuals
Alleged by
Defendant
South Wales Police |
Charges
brought
or reported
|
Charges or reports
Withdrawn or
Quashed
by whom? |
Conviction and which
charges |
Appeal
Which
charges |
Outcome of
Appeal
Judges? |
Vehicle, its
Nationality and name of
registered
keeper
|
|
|
|
|
A48-Cowbridge. Stopped defective light |
PS Huw Phillips
Helen Phillips CPS
Marianne Fanshawe
Ms J Caress
Clerk of Court |
PS Huw Phillips
Clare Willis
Insp. Sidney Griffiths
Linda Young
John Kirkpatrick
|
1.No insurance
2.No MOT
3. No Tax
4.Rectification ticket |
2. &3. Withdrawn by CPS |
1.& 2. Upheld in claimant's absence
24/5/93 |
All |
All Quashed in claimant's absence
03/6/93
|
Ford Escort
Guernsey
Marianne Fanshawe |
|
Veterinary surgery, Barry burgled again and thief caught by Claimant
(sample from 74 other incidents not in this schedule as blocked by successive members of HM Partnership) |
Inspector Sydney Griffiths
Inspector Manners
Inspector Trigg
Superintendant Jones
Police surveillance team parked right outside surgery |
Police refuse any disclosure at all |
|
|
|
|
|
Any selection from 15 vehicles would have been parked outside the surgery, at any one time, rotated daily, just to confuse Defendant but allow the Claimant to practice veterinary surgery |
|
Defective tyre outside Claimant's surgery at Tynewydd Road
Barry |
PS Jane Lott
Scott Parry
Inspector RI Manners
M Holmes
S Kirke
Inspector Price
Court Usher
|
PS Jane Lott
Insp. Coliandris |
1.Defective tyre
2.No Tax |
No. 2. by CPS |
Defective tyre |
1. |
Quashed
(PC altered traffic ticket between issue and Appeal)
17/12/93
Judge Birt |
Ford Escort
Guernsey
Marianne Fanshawe |
|
Arrested outside Claimant's surgery, Grand Avenue, Ely re BMW motor bike |
PC Phillip Thomas
BJ Price PC3150
Prison governor
Ian Williams
Dr Watson
Thomas PC3052
Inspector Trigg
M Powell |
DC Phillip Thomas
PC Beer
DC David Griffiths
DS Robert Powell
PC Paines
PS Huckfield
PS Denis Crutcher
PC Donovan
PC Brown |
1.Theft of bike 2.Garrotte type
Instrument
3.Assault
4.No insurance
4. No MOT
5.No tax
JAILED
25/5/93 |
All charges withdrawn by CPS |
|
|
|
BMW 1000cc
Motorcycle
Guernsey
Marianne Fanshawe |
|
Bridgend Police - stopped |
Duty Sargeant
Mrs Kirstie Kirk
passenger
|
PC Simon Rogers
Insp. Andrew Rice |
1.No Driving licence
2.No Insurance
3. No MOT |
All withdrawn by CPS or police? |
|
|
|
Escort Cabriolet
UK
Ms K Webb |
|
Stopped at St Nicholas, Vale of Glam - no VEL |
Mrs Kirstie Kirk
passenger |
PC Ivor Hillman
PC Billington
22/9/93 |
1.Driving whilst disqualified
2.No insurance
+?
04/10/93 |
All charges
Withdrawn by CPS |
|
|
|
Spitfire
UK
Amy Johnson |
|
Arrested in St Athan on suspicion of driving whilst disqualified. |
Stephen Booker
|
Stephen Booker
Ps Roy Goodman
PC McDonagh (deceased)
|
1.Driving whilst disqualified
2. No insurance
3. No tax
4.No MOT
JAILED |
All charges
Withdrawn by CPS |
|
|
|
BMW 1000cc Motorcycle
Guernsey
Joseph F Bloggins
|
|
After visiting Barry Police Station - stopped at roundabout outside. |
PC Kerslake
PC Simon Rodgers
PC Bassett
Jackie Seel
Jane Walker
Linda Holland
Judge Evans QC
|
Nigel Reid
DC Michael Hill
PC Julian Kerslake
PS Gareth Owen
PC Simon Rodgers
PS Alan Cowley |
1.Driving whilst disqualified
2.No insurance
3. No tax
4.No MOT
5. Fail to stop
6.Careless driving at 4 mph JAILED
|
1,3. and 4 withdrawn by police or CPS |
1)Fail to stop
2)without due care |
All |
All Upheld
Judge Evans |
Honda Act van
Guernsey
Maurice Kirk
|
|
Claimant's BMW motorbike stolen from rear of surgery, Tynewydd Road
|
Under cover surveillance police |
PC Christopher Driscoll
Insp. Sidney Griffiths |
Surveillance police removed number plates to obstruct stolen bike identification. |
N/A |
|
|
|
BMW 1000cc Motorcycle
Guernsey
Joseph F Bloggins |
|
Claimant alleges stopped on Manor Way, Cardiff , |
Duty sergeant Mrs Kirstie Kirk
passenger |
None as no record of incident |
1.Fail to produce
2.No insurance |
Withdrawn by CPS |
|
|
|
Ford Cabriolet
UK
Ms Kirstie Webb |
|
Pontypridd Road, Barry |
PC Kerslake
Insp. David Smith
Diane Graham
|
PC Kerslake
Insp. David Smith
Insp. Davies
PC Crabtree
09/08/94 |
1.Driving whilst disqualified
2. No insurance
3.No MOT
JAILED |
Withdrawn by CPS |
|
|
|
Spitfire
UK
Amy Johnson
|
|
Outside Barry Police Station - after release |
PC Kerslake
Insp. Howard Davies
2pm Duty Sergeant
Diane Graham |
Insp. Howard Davies
DC Venners
Insp. Smith
DI Kendall
PC Crabtree |
Criminal damage
JAILED
09/08/94 |
Withdrawn by police
|
|
|
|
Coroner's car
UK
|
|
Near Barry Police Station |
Linda Holland
Insp. Smith
Diane Graham |
Insp. Smith
DC Dinelle Francis
PS Roy Goodman
API Merit
Superintendant Francis |
1.Driving whilst disqualified
2. No
Insurance
+?
JAILED
10/08/94 |
All withdrawn
By CPS |
|
|
|
Spitfire
UK
Amy Johnson |
|
52/53Tynewydd Road, Barry - assault on Claimant by Paul Stringer |
PC John Johnson
Linda Holland
Diane Graham
21/07/95 |
PC Jonathan Johnson |
Stringer assault |
|
|
|
|
N/A |
|
51/53Tynewydd Road, Barry - further assault by Paul Stringer |
Mr Paul Stringer
Linda Holland
Diane Graham
Under cover
surveillance police
|
PC Martyn James |
Stringer
Actual Bodily Harm |
Charge against Stringer withdrawn due to" lack of evidence" |
|
|
|
N/A |
|
Claimant's Surgery - attempt to break in by Paul Stringer |
Mr Paul Stringer
Linda Holland
Insp. Sydney Griffiths
surveillance
police |
None as no record of incident |
N/A |
|
|
|
|
N/A |
|
Not stated - further assault by Paul Stringer |
Mr Paul Stringer
Linda Holland surveillance
police |
None as no record of incident |
N/A |
|
|
|
|
N/A |
|
52 Tynewwydd Road, Barry - criminal damage to property by Paul Stringer |
Mr Paul Stringer
Linda Holland
Diane Graham surveillance police |
None as no record of incident |
N/A |
|
|
|
|
N/A |
|
Claimant's Property,
Cardiff surgery,
Cowbridge Road |
Inspector Jenner
Ms Alison Jenner
Anthony Gaphael
Mr Peach
Mr G Thomas
Mr Harrison
Mr D Jones |
None as no record of incident |
1.Eviction of Tenants Act
2,Criminal damage |
All Charges withdrawn by CPS |
|
|
|
Police vehicles carrying, at least, a crow bar and sledgehammer
used to break into surgery |
|
Action 2 - CF101741
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Flight from Cardiff to Southern Ireland - Information laid before Barry Magistrates |
DC Murphy
DC Gibbs
PC McBride
Sue Jenkins
London CPS
RRB Munday
Christopher Paul
Ebbs
under cover surveillance police |
DC Murphy
DC Gibbs |
Breach of Terrorism Act
Feb 96
First interviewed
April 96? |
|
Stopped part heard
and
quashed |
|
|
1954 Piper Colt
Aircraft
UK
Maurice Kirk |
|
|
St Athan B4265 |
PCA Stephens
PC Simon Rogers
Diane Graham |
PC Andrew Stephen
PC Simon Rogers |
1.Careless driving
2.cross white line at 4mph
3. No insurance |
3. withdrawn by CPS |
1. Careless Driving.
2. Cross single white line at 4mph.
Guilty Plea rendered MK "unfit to practice veterinary medicine"
6th Jan 05 RCVS Judgment |
No. 1. only |
Quashed
Judge Gaskell |
Austin Allegro veterinary ambulance
UK
Amelia Earhart |
|
Barry - Link Road |
PC Roche
Diane Graham |
PC Andrew Roche |
1. defective bumper
2. cracked windscreen
3. defective light
4. No insurance
5. Fail to produce
6. no seat belt |
Utter
Confusion
No. 6 removed by CPS |
All remaining Upheld |
All charges
|
All quashed
PC altered traffic ticket
Presiding Judge? |
Ford Orion
UK
Buzz Aldrin
|
|
St Nicholas |
PS Rice and 2 full ‘paddy' wagons
PC Ridley
Ms J Caress
Dawn Hawkins
R Hirst
Mr Stoffa, CPS, |
None |
1.Speeding
2.No insurance |
|
Stopped Quashed
CPS file seized and prosecutor arrested |
|
|
Austin Allegro veterinary ambulance
UK
Amelia Earhart |
|
Southey Street, Barry |
PC G Holmes
Diane Graham |
DC McGregor
PS Greaves
PC Gareth Holmes |
Fail roadside breath test?
Fail produce documents
|
All Withdrawn by CPS |
|
|
|
Citroen, Volvo or one of six other vehicles
Leigh Mallory, Jean Batten or Joseph F Bloggins |
|
Flying - St Donats
Vale of Glamorgan |
Andrew Aishe
Air Traffic Traffic
Control Cardiff and Staverton airports
Williamson CAA |
PC Walters (Gwent Police)
PC Hayes
PC Philip Bracegirdle (Gwent Police) |
Reported to CAA
Flying without valid licence |
Draft charges Withdrawn |
|
|
|
1943 Piper Cub G-KIRK
Aircraft
UK
Maurice Kirk |
|
Pontypridd Road, Barry |
PC Abi Brown
SPC Lewis
Insp. Jonathan Lott
Dawn Hawkins
Diane Graham
|
PC Abi Brown
SPC Lewis
Insp. Jonathan Lott
Diane Griffiths |
1.Traffic light
2.No insurance
3. No MOT
4. Fail to produce documents
5. Fail roadside
Breath test
JAILED |
Zero reading at police station
No. 5. withdrawn |
1.Traffic light
2.No insurance
3. No MOT
4. Fail to produce docs
|
All charges |
All Quashed
Judge Jacobs |
Ford Estate
UK
D Williams MRCVS |
|
St Athan B4265/Llantwit major |
PC Kihlberg
PC Humphreys
Ms J Caress
Insp. Bohun
Dawn Hawkins
Judge Jacobs
Judge Seys Llewellyn
CPS |
PC Humpreys
PS Faulkner
PC Anthony Kihlberg
PC Gareth Holmes
Insp. Bohun
PC Uprichard
PC Keith Crabtree
Vivienne Teresa Davies |
1.Fail to supply Roadside breath test
2. No insurance
JAILED |
Claimant offered Obstruction charge by CPS, mid hearing, in place of ‘refuse breath test' |
Fail to supply Roadside breath test |
Fail to supply
Road side ‘chat' or breath test |
Upheld in claimant's absence.
Medical note ridiculed
Presiding judge? |
BMW 7 series
UK
Miss Jean Batten |
|
Link Road Breath Test - A4050 south of Junction 33 of M4 |
PC Guest
PC Wellbeloved |
PC Guest
PC Wellbeloved |
|
|
|
|
|
BMW 7 series
UK
Miss
Jean Batten |
|
Newport Road / Albany Road, Cardiff |
PC Osbourne
PS Geoffrey Roberts
PS Pickett
PS Mahony
Dr Lush
PC Price
PC Coles
Dawn Hawkins
Diane Graham
Miss B Kirk |
PC Osbourne
PS Geoffrey Roberts
PS Pickett
PS Mahony
Dr Lush
PC Price
PC Coles |
1.No seatbelt 2.Using mobile
3.Refuse roadside breath test
4.No insurance
5. No MOT
Beaten up JAILED and beaten up again |
1, 2 & 5
Withdrawn by CPS
4. Quashed |
Refuse road side breath test |
Refuse road side breath test |
Upheld
Presiding judge? |
Peugeot
UK
Miss B Kirk
|
|
A473 - towards Bridgend |
PC Rewbridge
Court manager
Chief Sup Jones
Unnamed police inspector, in well of court, caught signalling to police in witness box
Diane Graham
CPS
Judge N Cooke
All 12 members of the jury |
Insp. Steven Evans
PC Linda Rewbridge
PC Smith
PC Bowers |
Dangerous driving
Or
Driving without due
care
JAILED |
|
Stopped by judge to Order Not Guilty Verdict
Claimant instead is
Jailed
while RCVS
deny all knowledge
of incident |
|
|
Ford Escort Estate
UK
D Williams MRCVS
|
|
Church Street, Llantwit Major |
PC Kihlberg
PC Gareth Holmes
Diane Graham
|
PC Robert Morgan
PC Anthony Kihlberg
PC Gareth Holmes
PC David Barrett
Insp. Hubbard
PS McCarthy
PC Gary Hayes
PS Nigel Streeter |
Public Order
JAILED |
Withdrawn by CPS |
|
|
|
BMW 7 series
UK
Miss Jean Batten |
|
Outside Cardiff County Court |
PC Gunstone
Court security
Court manager
Diane Graham
|
PS Daryl Fahey
PC Gunstone
PC Stone |
Obstruction
JAILED |
Withdrawn by police |
|
|
|
VW Campaign Wagon
UK
Mrs VA Kirk |
|
Claimant Surgery 175 Cowbridge Rd Cardiff |
PC2673
PC301
Diane Graham |
PC 301 Zachary Mader |
1.No insurance
2. Fail to produce |
Withdrawn by CPS |
|
|
|
VW Campaign Wagon UK
Mrs VA Kirk |
|
Vale of Glamorgan Show - Fonmon |
PC Walters
Dennis Davies
Andrew Morris
S Kearsly-Evans
Insp. Howard Davies
Jackie Seel
Roger T Martin
Andrew Jones
Ieuan Rees
Diane Graham |
PC Walters
Insp. Christopher Patterson
PC Pearce
PS Rice
Insp. Howard Davies
Byron Williams
Simon Turner
Elaine Carr
Maurice Dwek |
JAILED
The ‘Complaint' before court is still undisclosed by Defendant having hidden it now from the Claimant, 11 judges and 18 magistrates. |
Withdrawn by
CPS |
|
|
|
Austin van
UK
Miss Amelia Earhart |
|
Cash Generators, Barry - stolen cheques |
Claimant alleges inaction by the Defendant and therefore does not name any officers as being involved |
PS Hubert James
PC Heidi Dilworth
PS Tumelty
PC Walker
PC Wintle
Mr Shaft
PC Bradbury |
|
|
|
|
|
N/A |
|
A473 Cowbridge Road, towards Bridgend |
Dawn Hawkins
Diane Graham |
PC Clive Barber
DS Davies |
No insurance |
Withdrawn by CPS in
court |
|
|
|
Ford Granada?
UK
Wilfred Barker |
|
Hayes Monument - Cardiff City Centre |
Mark Cocksey
PC Robert Osbourne
Dawn Hawkins
Diane Graham
|
PC Mark Cocksey
PC Robert Osbourne
PC Andy James
PS Linda Canterbury
PS Geoffrey Roberts
PC William Roberts
PC Adrian Williams
PC Tracey Selleck |
1.Driving whilst disqualified
2. No Insurance
+?
JAILED |
|
All dismissed |
|
|
VW Campaign Waggon
UK
Mrs VA Kirk |
|
Westgate, Cowbridge,
Vale of Glamorgan
Outside police station |
PC Bickerstaff
PC Holehouse
Court clerks
Dr M Coleman
Dr Baig
PS Robert Davidson
PS James Hall
Dawn Hawkins
Diane Graham
Volvo driver known to police
Passing van driver
|
PC Bickerstaff
PC Holehouse
PS Robert Davidson
PS Michael George
PS James Hall
PC Thomas Warren
PC David Giboney
PC Claire Baxter-Jones
PC Richard Collins
PC Damian Seaton
Dr A Baig
Dr Martin Coleman |
1.Driving whilst disqualified 2.PublicOrder
(frightened two large policemen)
3.No insurance
JAILED |
|
Number 2. |
No. 2 |
Stop by judge part heard and
quashed
Judge Pearce? |
VW Campaign Waggon
UK
Mrs Violet Alicia Kirk, Claimant's long suffering mother |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|